Grumpy Muppet: Revit Terminology and Other Rants

First off, thank you to all you smart people at Autodesk for the great work you are doing advancing design technology. Now, please listen...

Rant 1: Terminology

Friends at Autodesk, please review the terminology used in Revit. The inconsistency of terminology has been causing problems to new users for years. Here are some examples:

The tool to make a foundation wall is under the 'Structure' heading as Wall:Structure. This would be fine but the tool to make a strip footing is under the tab called 'Foundation' as 'Wall'.

To make a column footing you pick a tool called 'Isolated'. It's not isolated, it's under a column. A slab is more isolated than a Column Footing.

You can place a beam using the 'beam' tool, very logical. Now, where does one load more 'beams'? From the 'Structural Framing' folder. Are columns not also part of the frame?

And don't get me started on 'Families'. I devoted an entire post to translating 11 variables for family names...
http://revit.blogspot.ca/2010/09/revit-translation-naming-families.html

Rant 2: Seeing Levels and Grids in 3D

Okay, Autodesk has no excuse on this one. For over three years we have been able to see Datums in 3D in the Conceptual Mass template. Why can't we at least have the option to show this in the project template?! (I'm not even going to mention perspective mode in Vasari)

Rant 3: Revit Structure Sections

Last rant, is for Revit Structure. Actually, this is more of a wishlist item. Why can't we just load one section (W10x49 for example) and use it for all beams, columns and detail components?

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: Follow and Tweet @ORUGca to Win!

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: Follow and Tweet @ORUGca to Win!

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG BIM Process Prezipaper

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG BIM Process Prezipaper: Instead of the old 'whitepaper' format, we thought that a 'Prezipaper' might be more suitable to present a topic as dynamic ...

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: Behind the Revit Curtain with Greg Demchak

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: Behind the Revit Curtain with Greg Demchak: Here's Greg Demchak's presentation from our September 19th meeting. Look 'Behind the Revit Curtain' with Greg Demchak... ...

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG Meeting Sept.19 Behind the Revit Curtain

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG Meeting Sept.19 Behind the Revit Curtain: Subject: ORUG - Behind the Revit Curtain ...

Revit 2013 Transparency Bug

Yes, I said 'bug'. I also say 'problem'. So, for this bug problem, there is a patch.

Read this blog posting from the Autodesk team, it contains the link to the 'hotfix'.
http://revitclinic.typepad.com/my_weblog/2013/01/revit-2013-hotfix-available.html

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG at RTC North America 2013

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: ORUG at RTC North America 2013: ORUG was well represented at RTC North America, in Vancouver. The quality of sessions was excellent as were the conversations and networkin...

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: InfraWorks Video

Ontario Revit Users Group Blog: InfraWorks Video: Last ORUG meeting we dabbled with InfraWorks.  I made the video above inside of InfraWorks and it was really fun and easy. Next meeting ...

InfraWorks for Building Design Suite Ultimate 2014

I've been learning InfraWorks and have to say that it's amazing. I should say that it has amazing potential. Creating your design in the context of a real-world environment is so powerful. All that is left is for Autodesk to integrate Oculus Rift support and we have a true virtual experience. It's so easy to use, like a video game (SimCity). When I say 'easy' I mean compared to getting a similar result in another software. You need to know (or learn) something about coordinate systems, raster images, terrain models etc.

Autodesk has broken up the product into various versions...

For some reason the Building Design Suite Ultimate, which has Revit, doesn't have the Revit import in InfraWorks. Whereas the InfraWorks in the Infrastructure Design Suite does import Revit directly. While you can use FBX for the Building Design Suite Ultimate version it won't be a 'live' database link. Then again, maybe you don't want that to clog your InfraWorks model.
There are other differences and we are still discovering those, I will post as I learn.

Here's a video on how InfraWorks might be used.

Revit Wall Area 'Misunderstanding'

Revit (and by extension Navisworks) wall areas and volumes are calculated based upon the centre of the wall. Because of this, there is no automatic way to get an 'actual' wall face area or volume. There is no way around this that I know of. For instance, I have tried  material schedules, wall wraps and paint tool. The good news is if you know this, you can compensate for it. Also, the bigger your building the less you will be 'off' by percentage.

Questions:

1. Does anyone have a reliable workaround that I have missed?

2. Is anyone using 'Parts' for this?

2. Why does Autodesk insist on leaving it this way? Is there a good reason it is the way it is?

Revit Technology Conference North America 2014

You might notice a little image on the top right of my blog for Revit Technology Conference North America 2014. My advice to you is, just go to this top BIM conference. Happily SolidCAD, the company I work for, agrees with this and will be sending me this year. I will also be joined by other members of the Ontario Revit Users Group who hope to bring back some BIM wisdom to Ontario. Keep an eye on this blog for updates on my journey to RTC NA...

Building Design Suite 2014 Unistaller

Righting a wrong is always good. In this case, for the Autodesk 2014 suites, Autodesk has provided an uninstall tool. I'm running it right now after mistakenly installing standalone versions when I should have installed network versions. As opposed to spending an entire day hunting down files in various and sundry locations. But we will still have to do that for previous versions. Thank you Autodesk for righting a wrong, now please provide us an uninstall tool for previous suites versions. This tool will uninstall AutoCAD(not Revit) 2013 based suites.

What Revit Wants: Extents of Revit 2013 Railings bug - when no balus...

What Revit Wants: Extents of Revit 2013 Railings bug - when no balus...: Basically, when all the balusters are removed from a Railing definition in Revit 2013, I have observed that the 'flip control' moves...

Bring Plant 3D into Revit

If you are trying to integrate 3D information from Autodesk Plant 3D into Revit use the following method.

1. Open Plant 3D file (in Plant 3D, of course)
2. In the command line type: exporttoautocad

You should get a clean result like this when the file is imported into Revit.

 As opposed to something like the image below which was 'saved as' (not exported).

Revit OpEd: What is Revit and BIM Resource

Revit OpEd: What is Revit and BIM Resource: Alex Gore and his firm F9 Productions have created, as part of their company website, a resource for people that are just getting started ...

Import 3DsMAX into Navisworks 2013 BUG

Earlier this year I did a post on importing Sketchup into Navisworks, and how great it works. So a clients asks, 'can you do the same from 3DsMAX to Navisworks 2013?'. The answer is no, geometry will export but all materials will be missing. Autodesk is aware of this bug and is working on it.

DWF works fine
I haven't tried this on 2014

Linked AutoCAD Survey into Revit Rotation Bug

We have noticed a 'Linked AutoCAD Survey into Revit Rotation Bug'. In other words, our linked AutoCAD files keep rotating in a Revit site view. We're not sure why, but are sure it is happening and we've seen it since version 2011 or earlier.

Here's a video to help work around this issue...

Revit Apps, Add-ons, Plugins, Extensions and Whatever Else You Want to Call Them

First I begin with a rant, then we get to the good stuff.

1. Autodesk does not put forth unified naming conventions. For instance is this article about Apps, Add-ons, Plugins, Extensions or Tools? What's the difference? I don't know.

2. Apps are a pain to download, install and keep updating. 

3. Most Apps do not behave in a 'Revit' way. In other words, they are one directional. For instance there is an App to change all of the Room and Door numbers. Nice, but you have to rerun the app on the entire model every time you make a change.

4. Autodesk relies too much on third parties to fix or explain their software.

Now that the rant is over, Apps are a necessary evil. So let me try to explain some of the hundreds of Apps, Add-ons, Plugins, Extensions and other tools available for Revit. All of the Autodesk Apps are 'free'. Some of the Apps made by other companies are not free but very low cost, especially if they save time. Therefore I'm not going to focus on price in this list. I'm going to highlight the 'must-have' Apps.

There are four main ways to find Apps.

Autodesk Subscription Site
Autodesk Labs
Autodesk Apps Exchange Site
Individual Company Sites

When you install them they will appear in the Ribbon. I can't guarantee where exactly or what they will be called.

Autodesk Subscription

You can download Apps from the Autodesk Subscription site from the Product Enhancement link.

Autodesk Revit DB Link 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Import and export data between an Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013, or Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013 project and an external database, and then more easily maintain relationships of linked data with Autodesk® Revit® DB Link.

• A grid view of the data enables you to make any final edits before import.

• Databases can be updated following internal or external changes.

• The grid control enables you to create Revit shared parameters to add new fields to related tables in the database.

• Changes to new fields within the database automatically update Revit shared parameters upon future imports.

My Review:

Has potential but needs quite a bit of back-end support and setup.

Autodesk Revit Model Review 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Automate the process of reviewing and auditing building information modeling (BIM) projects in Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013, or Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013 software with the Autodesk® Revit® Model Review plug-in:

• Check the accuracy and consistency of a Project or Family against standards set by your firm, your clients, or industry best practices.

• Correct inconsistencies with a single click or with instructions provided when manual fixes are required.

. 

My Review:

It works as stated and can be useful for projects that impose a standard.

Batch Print for Autodesk Revit 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Batch Print provides an easy way to print a large number of drawings (views and sheets) from a Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013, or Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013 software project. 

After preparing the default printer and the Revit software project, use Batch Print to send any number of drawings to the printer and to control the order in which they print. When you start the print job, Batch Print manages the printing of the drawings, requiring no further interaction from you. If desired, you can monitor the progress of the print job using a status dialog. 

Batch Print is compatible with the 32-bit and 64-bit versions of Revit 2013, Revit Architecture 2013, Revit Structure 2013, and Revit MEP 2013 software.

My Review:

Just okay. Can't pick another printer other than the default.

eTransmit for Autodesk Revit 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

With eTransmit for Autodesk® Revit® 2013 software products, you can copy a Revit model and dependent files to a single folder for Internet transmission. You can transmit any model that has been upgraded to Revit Release 2012 or later and saved.

With eTransmit for Autodesk Revit, you can:

• Copy and detach a Revit model and associated files to a single folder for internet transmission. This removes the typical error messages when you copy central files using the operating system.

• Locate dependent files automatically and include them in the transmittal folder, helping to reduce the possibility of error. All dependent files are automatically converted to use relative paths so the dependent files can be located by the model.

• Choose to include related dependent files such as linked Revit models, CAD files, DWF™ markups, decal images, and external keynote files. You can transmit any Revit (.rvt) model that has been upgraded to be compatible with a Revit 2012 software product or later.

• Choose to Upgrade the Revit (.rvt) model and linked models to the current release.

• Choose to remove unused families, materials, and other objects from the Revit projects to reduce file size.

• Transmit models that are using file-based worksharing or server-based worksharing. eTransmit for Revit can also work with non-workshared Revit models.

My Review:
Nice, useful app. Does exactly what it says it will do.

Globe Link for Autodesk Revit 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Globe Link for Revit 2013 platform products helps users streamline preliminary project planning by enabling them to present conceptual designs in the context of the project site.

With Globe Link, users can publish 3D building information models directly from Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013, and Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013 software into Google Earth™ mapping service. Users can also acquire site information from Google Earth mapping service and import it into Revit 2013 software applications for building and site layout purposes. Globe Link is optimized for Google Earth version 5 mapping service.

Globe Link is compatible with the 32-bit and 64-bit versions of Revit 2013, Revit Architecture 2013, Revit Structure 2013, and Revit MEP 2013 software.

Content is currently available in English only

My Review:

The scale is off when importing and exporting.You need to purchase the Google Earth Pro for even a remote chance of this working.

Revit Extensions for Autodesk Revit 2013

First I'm going to state that most of these are 'throw-ins'  from Autodesk's purchase of Robobat. I think you might guess how good a 'throw-in' is. That said, there are some useful ones here, especially the Import and Export Apps. 

What Autodesk says it does:

Revit® Extensions for Autodesk® Revit® 2013 extend the capabilities of Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013, and Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013 software in key areas, including structural analysis, modeling, reinforcement, interoperability and construction documentation. This download contains all previously released Revit Extensions and updates. The Q3 Update includes enhancements to bridge modeling, integration with Autodesk® Robot™ Structural Analysis Professional 2013, and improvements to the reinforcement extensions. Refer to the “Feature Summary” for details.

Robot Structural Analysis 2013 

Integration with Autodesk® Robot Structural Analysis 2013 

Integration with Autodesk® Concrete Building Structures 2013 ***Load Takedown *

Composite Design

Reinforcement Design 

AutoCAD Structural Detailing 2013

Integration with AutoCAD® Structural Detailing 2013 (Formwork Drawings) 

Integration with AutoCAD® Structural Detailing 2013 (Steel) 

Reinforcement Drawings 

Simulation

Beams (Static Analysis) 

Frames (Static Analysis)

Trusses (Static Analysis)

Slabs (Static Analysis) 

Conceptual Form Simulation 

Floor Vibrations Analyzer

Gravity Column Designer

Reinforcement

Beams

Columns 

Continuous footings

Pile caps

Slab openings

Spread footings

Walls

Walls corners

Piles 

Parapets 

Slab corners 

Retaining walls 

Interferences of reinforcing bars 

Automatic Reinforcement Generation 

Bridges

Integration with AutoCAD® Civil 3D® 2013 : you need to have Civil 3D installed and open on your desktop for this to work

Roads and Terrain

Bridge ‐ Concrete slab with girders

Bridge ‐ Concrete box girder 

Bridge ‐ Concrete slab 

Documentation 

Customization of bridge families

Steel connections

Beam to column ‐ end‐plated
Column base

Both of these tools add a connection family to the selected objects. If you need to change a conenction, you will be better to erase the old one a put a new one in place (re-run the add-on).

Timber

Wood Framing Walls

Modeling

Excel® Based Model Generation

Frame Generator

Grids Generator

Import/Export

CIS/2 Import 

CIS/2 Export 

SDNF Import 

SDNF Export 

Miscellaneous

Elements Positioning

Freeze Drawings-makes a dwg of the view you are in and then inserts and explodes that dwg. Not a good tool from a best practices point of view. It would be better if it created a native Revit drawing.

Compare Models

Text Generator: import a txt file and configure

Content Generator: make structural families based upon a parametric dialog box.

Shared Parameters Converter

Roombook Areabook Extension for Autodesk Revit 2013 and Autodesk Revit LT 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

The Roombook Areabook Extension for Autodesk® Revit® 2013*, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013, Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013, and Autodesk® Revit LT™ software helps calculate the surface area of walls, floors and ceiling elements, room circumferences and the total number of furnishing elements within a project.

In addition to the automated detection of room areas and surfaces, this extension helps users configure these elements manually to local requirements, as well as achieve more accurate model take-offs. Quantified results can be exported to Microsoft® Excel® software and Autodesk® Quantity Takeoff (QTO) software.

My Review:

Great. Does exactly what it says it does. There is a video which explains this plugin in detail. There is a part of the video that says that the schedules can be reimported into Revit as native schedules. I could not find out how to do this. 

Space Naming Utility for Autodesk Revit MEP 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

The Space Naming Utility for Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013 software is an intuitive tool that automatically assigns the names and numbers from architectural rooms to Revit MEP spaces. By downloading the Space Naming Utility for Revit MEP 2013 software, you can eliminate the need to manually assign names to the spaces, helping save time and simplifying your workflow.

Timber Roof Framing Extensions for Revit 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Roof Framing Extensions for Autodesk® Revit® 2013 software applications is comprised of two extensions that help automate modeling of roofs in Autodesk Revit, Autodesk Revit Structure and Autodesk Revit Architecture software applications.

The Rafter Framing extension enables the definition and generation of various types of “A” frame roof models. Another extension creates truss roof systems.

Structural elements are created based on a selected Revit native roof object. Generated timber roof structures can be exported to Autodesk® Robot® Structural Analysis software to perform further structural analysis and design tasks.

My Review:

Worksharing Monitor for Autodesk Revit 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

Worksharing Monitor facilitates the use of Autodesk® Revit® 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Architecture 2013, Autodesk® Revit® Structure 2013, or Autodesk® Revit® MEP 2013 software in a worksharing environment, in which multiple people work on one project. For workshared projects, Worksharing Monitor answers questions such as:

• Who is currently working on this project?
• Is my local copy of the project up-to-date?
• When will my Save to Central operation finish?
• Has my request to borrow elements been granted?
• Are any issues interfering with my work on a Revit software project?

Note: Worksharing Monitor is not useful for standalone Revit software projects, which do not use worksharing to divide the work for a project among several people.

Worksharing Monitor is compatible with the 32-bit and 64-bit versions of Revit 2013, Revit Architecture 2013, Revit Structure 2013, and Revit MEP 2013 software.

My Review:

A must-have for projects that are 'workshared'. Doesn't work with Revit Server yet.

Autodesk Labs

These tools are usually interesting but are not finished nor permanent. This is to be expected because Labs is made for research and development. Don't let that discourage you, there are some good apps here.

Project Chronicle

Really interesting tool, it records your screen, voice AND commands (but not all of them). I see potential in this.

Project Bluestreak

This is an Instant Messenger which will also send updates as to when the model has been Synced to Central. This is very a useful tool as it works with Revit Server (where the Worksharing Monitor does not). This technology will likely replace or change the Worksharing Monitor. 

Autodesk Exchange Apps

Level Generator

What Autodesk says it does:

This plugin can be used to generate multiple levels with one command. It also creates plan views and the ceiling views for the new levels. Users can manually draw levels level by level. Building the model that has a lot of levels can be tedious and time consuming. This tool can help generate levels quickly.

My Review:
Simple to use and works well.

Wall Opening Area

This plug-in calculates the sum of opening areas on each wall and stores the values as two shared parameters on walls.

My Review:
Simple to use and works well. The areas are filled out under the Other category in the properties of the wall. You can also use the information in the wall schedule.



Revit IFC Export Alternate UI 2013

What Autodesk says it does:

This application provides an alternate user interface for the export of IFC files from Revit 2013. This new user interface offers additional options not provided in the standard Revit user interface, and provides the ability to store setup configurations into the Revit model for reuse.

File Upgrader

File Upgrader will batch upgrade previous versions of Revit files to the Revit 2013 format. The tool is intended to help upgrade family contents, template files as well as project files. 

My Review:

Useful and simple

Other Companies...

I apologize if I've missed some companies but here are a few of the ones I know of...

Tools4Revit

Smart Family Browser

Nice way of visually selecting and previewing Families. You can filter through folders and projects.

Quick Table

Useful and simple to use. Import Excel or Word Table into Drafting View

Sort and Mark

Very useful, powerful and simple to use. This will renumber anything ie. grids, rooms, doors. Cool thing is, as you add more Grids, it automatically renumbers them. It can also add facing direction of windows, walls, doors etc. 

Ideate

BIM Explorer

Very useful selection and filter tool.

Case

Case Add-in Manager
This tool is used to install and remove CASE Add-Ins from any version of Revit. We will no longer build ClickOnce installers for any of the free tools. You may also notice a little preview for our upcoming subscription tools


External Wall Facings
Very useful. This tool will put a N, E, S or W in the comments of exterior wall indicating direction. Useful for energy calculations and glass ratios.

Selection Set Manager
Simple tool that will remember selection sets. 

Batch Export Families
This tool will export all of the Families in a project to a folder. Nice.

Kiwicodes

Project Browser

A slick new Project Browser. Autodesk would do well to notice the way this is executed.

Family Browser

Another really nice looking tool that Autodesk should notice. Similar to the Palettes idea from AutoCAD Architecture this tool displays all of the families in a nice graphic display. You are able to make tabs etc. Works across the network.

CTC Express Tools

CTC Watermark

A lot of people ask about how to 'secure' families that they make. This seems to be the only way possible. I wasn't able to try this one as the Revit Express Tools trial expired on my machine.



BIM Object

Not an app as much as a link to the BIMContent website. The website reminds me of Autodesk seek. Nice European content.

Boost your BIM

Image-O-Matic
Useful tool. This tool will animate a parametric family. Here's a video.



Revolution Design

Run by Stephen Faust this company makes apps and consults on custom ones. He offers three main products; Keynote Manager, Revit Workflow and Selection Master. These tools were obviously made by a Revit user. I gave them a quick try and am impressed. I would recommend that you download the trials and give these a try.

viewRename

This is a great app! I used it by renaming some interior elevations. It will simply name the view according to the room and orientation. Simple, but what an great way to improve a messy Project Browser among other things. 

autoLink
Nice tool for making view references. You can refer to another sheet simply by typing and then the autoLink tool will update the reference if the sheet number changes.

Finish Floors
Again, a nice, simple and effective tool. This tool will make a finish floor in a room with one click.

Keynote Manager
This is also a great app for firms who may already use Revit but are looking to gain efficiency. This suite of tools will allow you to make Keynotes, keep track of when they change and share with spec writers. 


KKM Soft

Workload Monitor
Free download is available. Looks like a good idea but it's not finished. Tracks how long a user is working in a given project. 



Whitefeet

Run by Mario Guttman, formerly of HOK now with CASE. Mario has made some really useful apps here. I plan on reviewing all of his apps more in-depth.

Sheet Manager: Links to an Excel file. Creates or updates sheets in Revit as a bulk editing process.

Revit-Database Link: Connect to either an Access or a SQL Server database and synchronize data in both directions.

Model Builder: Import and export Revit elements in a way that allows geometry exchange with other programs.

Amazing potential for this tool. Exports objects out to excel with coordinates.

Area & Mass Tools: Placing unplaced areas; creating solid forms from areas; and counting the floors in a mass object.

Room Tools: Placing unplaced rooms; creating rooms from areas; and, creating solid forms from rooms.

View Tools: Creating views from rooms; tagging views; exporting images from views; and, creating sheets from views.

This tool is the main reason why I downloaded the suite of apps. This tool is truly awesome. Makes views out of rooms, places views on sheets, makes 3D Section Box views of plan views. Amazing tool.

Parameter Tools: String and number manipulation; relating data between object types; and, importing and exporting of model data.

Family Tools: Exporting detailed information about families, symbols and tags; importing parameters; and, batch processing families.

Schedule Tools: Working with schedules and key schedules with Excel; editing instance values; creating a table and type schedule.

Management Tools: Displaying the various forms of classification use with families; and, managing attachment links.

Revitworks

Door Factory: This app is not cheap but is certainly a good value. It's purpose is to make 'any' door family quickly. You choose units, swings, frames, hardware and more from a logically developed, tabbed dialogue box. I installed the trial version which is limited to single swing doors. I'm really impressed and will be trying their other products. (I discovered that it will not operate if your Windows font size is anything other than 'smallest'. I'm not really fond of changing my windows settings to accommodate an app.)

BIMRay

ColorByNumber: When former Revit programmers come up with an App, take notice. This app addresses the core issue of BIM - managing the information. Many of us understand things better when they are displayed in COLOUR (as opposed to displayed as text or numbers in a schedule). In my review of this product I used it to simply and quickly display walls with different thicknesses in unique colours - totally easy. Also to note, the downloading and installation of this app was very slick. I believe BIMRay will be so important I have made their links 'affiliate links'.

KrispCAD

Wall Join Manager

This looks like a simple app which could save much more than $2 worth of time.

Autodesk Site Designer

This was released September 17th, 2014 for Autodesk Subscribers. This set of tools was developed by EaglePoint Software a few years ago. The best part of this tool is the LandXML Import/Export. I have played with the other tools over the years and never really found they were user-friendly enough to recommend. Now that it's 'free' I will spend a little more time trying them out. 

You might want to download the Users Guide here because Autodesk has not been forthcoming with their own.

Spiteful CAD Imports-Repost

This article comes from the blog do-u-revit by Dave Baldacchino and Steven Campbell. I'm re-blogging this because I feel it's an important workaround. I also feel that Autodesk should be addressing this in the program and not relying so much on outside apps.

I also wrote an article on the dangers of importing CAD here.

Spiteful CAD Imports

So this week the buildingSMART managers at HOK were discussing ways to get rid of imported (BAD!!) CAD files in Revit projects. Should be something that is easy to do, right? Well, not so easy it turns out.

If you need to do this, you might simply fork out a little cash for a custom plugin. Autodesk Exchange has a good number of such things available and my cohort Brok Howard pointed me to Purge Cads. I have not tried it, but I did confirm with the developer that it does not touch linked CAD files, so for a couple of bucks, this will get the job done fast.

One way or another, you need a plugin. In my case I had Ideate Explorer at my disposal. Unfortunately it lumps CAD Imports & Links together. If you have this plug-in, here’s what you might call “an obscene work-around” to hack your way to the finish line:

• Assuming you have worksharing enabled, have another user go to the Manage Links dialog and re-load all loaded CAD Links and load & unload all unloaded CAD Links. All we need is to have another user borrow these linked instances so we can get their name in the following step;
• Go to the Manage Links dialog and try to load/unload the links. You will then get a list of CAD links that you don’t have permission to edit (the ones touched by the other user in the above step). Take note of the names;

• In Ideate Explorer, select all CAD Imports/Links, then go to the Revit filter and de-select the instances listed above.

• Now delete the selection and the links will be retained.

Autodesk (or Ideate), if you’re reading this, don’t you think our lives can be simplified by a smidgen? This type of functionality should just be built into the product. The amount of solutions we have to default to via plug-ins is getting way out of hand!